Home / Field Reports
Field Report No. 02 · Cost of marketing
One ratio governs the budget.
Cost of marketing as a percentage of revenue: the definition, the target band, the flag, the cut line, and a real ledger from our own books.
Get my free auditListen to this Field Note on The Capstone Brief
Cost of marketing, run on your numbers.
Everything you spend on marketing, divided by revenue. It is the one number every vendor, channel and dollar should answer to. Rented leads push it up every year. Owned visibility pushes it down, and the direction of that number is the whole argument.
Right in range, with room for $250,000 more at 15%.
This is inside the target band. The framework calls it healthy.
A healthy 10 to 15% here is $500,000, $750,000.
The zones.
Run it two ways: company-wide to check the budget is sized right, and per channel to find where the money works. Then hold both to the same standard: healthy at 10 to 15%, check at 15 to 20%, red flag over 20%.
The zones, on one scale
Cost of marketing, company-wide or by channel. Bands are drawn for reading, not to scale.
Show the numbers
| Cost of marketing | Reading | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| Under 10% | Below the band | A growth conversation |
| 10 to 15% | Healthy | Keep running it |
| 15 to 20% | Check | A hard look at the next planning cycle |
| Over 20% | Red flag | A meeting this month and a date to fix it or cut it |
Source: Capstone’s operating framework, built from running marketing budgets inside a Northwest Ohio home services company. Not an industry survey.
One program, held to the number.
A canvassing program built from a standing start and run against this framework as it climbed. A trajectory is one thing; the receipt below is a single year counted to the dollar.
Source: internal program ledger, 2019 to 2023. Figures rounded. See how the program was built.
The receipt, 2021, fully loaded.
One year of that program with every cost counted: payroll, management, materials and the van. We publish it because 15.5% fully loaded is what the standard looks like on a real ledger. The flattering version of this number leaves payroll out. We do not run the flattering version.
Source: internal program ledger, fiscal 2021. The full story behind this ledger.
The bands in dollars.
The same 10 to 15% lands very differently depending on the size of the business it is measured against.
These are operating targets for established home service companies, not a law of nature. A company entering a new market runs hot on purpose, with a date attached, instead of by drift. What the money buys at each size.
Run it this week.
The whole calculation takes an afternoon and a year of invoices. Here is the order.
- Pull twelve months of marketing cost, all of it. Ad accounts, retainers, lead fees, software, sponsorships and marketing payroll. If you are debating whether something counts, it counts.
- Divide by revenue and face the number. Most contractors land somewhere surprising: under 8% and coasting, or over 20% with no idea which channel did it.
- Split it by channel, even roughly. Perfect attribution does not exist in the trades, and honest approximation beats none. Ask every customer how they found you and write it down.
- Apply the bands and schedule the conversations. Anything from 15 to 20% gets a hard look at the next planning cycle. Anything over 20% is a red flag: a meeting this month, and a date to fix it or cut it. Under 10% company-wide is a growth conversation, not a virtue.
What owners ask.
Why measure marketing as a revenue percentage instead of a fixed budget?
A fixed budget goes stale the moment revenue moves. A percentage scales with the business, makes channels comparable to each other, and makes this year comparable to last year. Budgets get defended; ratios get answered.
Does marketing payroll belong in COM%?
Yes. A $70K in-house marketer is a marketing cost exactly the way a $70K retainer is. Leaving payroll out makes in-house look cheap and agencies look expensive, and the 15.5% ledger above counts the program’s payroll for that reason.
How do you apply COM% to channels you cannot attribute, like branding or TV?
Hold them to the company-wide number and to directional evidence: branded search volume, direct traffic, and how-did-you-hear-about-us answers on intake. Unattributable is not unaccountable.
Is a lower COM% always better?
No. Under 10% usually means the company is harvesting reputation instead of building pipeline, which is fine until the referral well runs dry. The target is a band, not a floor to race toward.
Where do the COM% thresholds come from?
From operating marketing budgets inside a Northwest Ohio home services company, including the 15.5% canvassing ledger above and a $20K per month TV test cut after it ran far past the 20% red flag. They are Capstone’s operating framework, not an industry survey.
What is your number?
One page of findings: your COM% computed from real figures, where each channel sits against the bands, and what we would fix first. Free, no meeting required.
Get my free audit